Supplement 15 Nov 26 - The Rear-View Mirror
"You can never plan the future by the past." - Edmund Burke, A Letter to a Member of the National Assembly, 1791
This week's quote pertains to the Deep Dive - and to the forecasters, who've spent most of this year planning the future by the past. NIESR calls its own 1% productivity assumption optimistic, because the economy averaged 0.4% a year from 2008 to 2023 (a stretch that included a financial crisis, austerity, Brexit and a pandemic, mind). The OBR tells us recent growth has been stronger than it expected, and structural - and then pencils in 1% for 2027. Burke was writing about French revolutionaries rather than economists, of course, but I think he'd have recognised the Treasury's referees. On Thursday the ONS told us the economy grew 0.7% in the third quarter. The rear-view mirror is a lovely thing to have - but it's a terrible way to drive!
As the forecasters start sketching out 2027, our next Property Business Workshop is Thursday 7th January 2027, in Birmingham, with myself and Rod Turner. We take on Strategic Planning, Productivity, Systems and Processes and Financial Management and Reporting all in one day - which is the toolkit you'll want for a year where the numbers will matter more than the headlines. Start your 2027 the right way and make the most of the opportunities that are inevitably in front of us all! Super Early Bird tickets are on sale now, with a genuine 20%+ discount on face value. Book in now at https://tinyurl.com/AdamRod27 - and grab a VIP dinner ticket if you want to talk through your own business in more detail!
Welcome back to Trumpwatch. The first full week after the midterms, and the President managed to go from "positive momentum toward an end to this Conflict" on Monday to "We don't need a deal with Iran" on Thursday - which, even by the standards of this section, is quite a round trip in four days. Last week I said I didn't expect him to go without a fuss, and that the "lame duck" idea looked extremely unlikely to me. Well - he hasn't, and it doesn't, and we've still got seven weeks of the old Congress to go.
Monday first. After meeting Qatar's prime minister at the White House, the President posted that "We are seeing positive momentum toward an end to this Conflict" (capital C, as is his way). He said America was "locked and loaded", but that more strikes were "quite unlikely" because the big Gulf allies "would prefer the status quo". He'd also told reporters at the weekend that he expects to meet Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin at the APEC summit in Shenzhen on 18th and 19th November - "and that'll be interesting", as he put it. I suspect it will. It would be his third meeting with Xi this year, with the trade truce between the two of them due to run out in January, and he says Iran and "denuclearisation" will be on the table. If you'd told me in February that the road to peace in the Gulf might run through Shenzhen, I'd have laughed - but here we are. It might be a good thing. We know China is self-interested in peace here. Xi has his respect and is the only one with the real might to keep him on his toes.
Tuesday brought Iran's answer. Abbas Araghchi, the foreign minister, said the conflict won't be solved by military means or more sanctions, only by "a language of respect" and by meeting Iran's conditions - which still include an end to the war on all fronts, the frozen assets released, the oil sanctions lifted and the American counter-blockade of Iran's ports ended. Mohsen Rezaei, rather less diplomatically, told Washington to "surrender". Qatar, still doing most of the heavy lifting alongside Pakistan, said there was progress and that "We remain hopeful". And over in Paris, at the G7, the Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband called for an all-out diplomatic effort to get beyond the "no war, no peace" stalemate - which is about as good a description of the last few months as I've seen.
Wednesday was Veterans Day, and the President told his audience "we must have a total victory" and that the war would be over "soon". A Reuters/Ipsos poll finished on Monday had 71% of Americans in favour of legislation to halt the war - and with a Democratic Congress arriving in January, that's not just an opinion poll any more (four senators were already calling for limits on the war's funding by Thursday). From January, of course, the money for the war has to get through a Democratic House and a Democratic Senate - and if you want to know why the White House might prefer a blockade to a bombing campaign, I'd start there.
Then Thursday. On Truth Social - "We don't need a deal with Iran" - with America holding billions in frozen Iranian assets and, in his words, controlling the Strait. The Washington Post reported he was dialling back the diplomacy, keeping the naval blockade in place, and closing down the dealmaking JD Vance had been leading (the Vice President should focus on corruption at home instead, apparently). Remember Vance blaming the war for the midterm defeat, a week earlier? It took the President about seven days to move him off the file. I'll leave you to draw your own conclusions on that one!
In two interviews the same day, he said he'd have "no hesitation" in striking again (to Hugh Hewitt), that America could destroy Iran's energy infrastructure, bridges and factories within three days if it chose to (to Stephen A. Smith), and that it would be "a defeat" if the regime was still in power at the end of his term. Iran's President Pezeshkian, for his part, accused Israel of deceiving Trump into the war in the first place. So we've a President who says he doesn't need a deal, but would count the regime surviving as a defeat - square that circle if you can.
Which brings us to Israel. Gadi Eisenkot, President Herzog's choice to form a government, is busy building a coalition - and warning against another round with Iran. Channel 13 reported that the army told him there's no immediate urgency for Israel to strike, and Netanyahu's office spent part of the week denying a report of a "shouting match" with the President over Iran (they called it "nonsense"). On Friday, Axios had the director of Mossad in Washington for talks on the war, which briefly lifted oil to its high of the day. I said last week that if the gap between what Trump wanted and what Netanyahu wanted got solved from the Israel end, it would be a different conversation altogether. It looks to me like that conversation has started - slowly.
So where are we? No deal, no strikes, a blockade running both ways and a President who says he doesn't need a deal - "no war, no peace", to borrow the Foreign Secretary's phrase. If anything, I think the odds of a renewed bombing campaign have dropped this week rather than risen (the Gulf allies want the status quo, Israel's likely next government isn't keen, and Congress is about to get a say on the money). But the odds of a proper peace haven't risen much either, and the Strait is still a long way from normal.
Oil - and the market took the "no war" half of that more seriously than the "no peace" half. Brent's January contract settled at $95.84 on Friday, against $98.32 a week earlier - down 2.5%, and a second weekly fall in a row. It dropped more than $7 on Monday to its lowest since late August, hit a 10-week low, recovered to about $92.70 by Wednesday's settlement and then drifted up through Thursday and Friday. WTI settled at $88.56, from $90.83. The late October peak was nearer $118, so Brent's about $22 below where it was three weeks ago.
The bigger oil story, to be honest, was the International Energy Agency saying on Friday that the market will be in surplus this quarter for the first time since the war began - with Gulf crude finding its way out by routes that avoid the Strait, American stocks building and OPEC+ pumping more. That's the supply side telling us the war premium has room to shrink further, provided nobody starts shooting again. I wouldn't bet on the $70s just yet - but $95 against $118 is a big help to our inflation numbers.
Over to the American economy, which had a hot week. October's CPI, out on Tuesday, rose 0.4% on the month against 0.3% expected, and core rose 0.3% against 0.2% - the third month in a row at 0.3%. There's no annual figure this time, because the Bureau of Labor Statistics didn't collect any prices in October 2025 during last year's government shutdown, so there's nothing to compare it with (you couldn't make it up!). September's annual rate was 3.7%.
Then the Fed. Christopher Waller, speaking in London a few hours before the release, said a half-point rise should be considered in December if core came in around 0.3% - and it did - and that only 25bp might put the Fed's credibility at risk. The 2-year Treasury jumped 14 basis points on Tuesday to 4.69%, the 10-year 6.5 to 4.93%, and by Thursday the dollar was at its highest since May 2025. A rise at the 8th-9th December meeting was priced at close to 90% after the data, with about a 13% chance of a half point. So Kevin Warsh looks set to raise rates in December whatever his boss thinks about it - and I doubt the boss will keep his thoughts to himself. He got away with the first one - the boss won’t want these nuances, we are about 5 levels too deep for the Prez - so, Godspeed, Kevin.
The stock market, meanwhile, decided last week's AI wobble was overdone. CoreWeave jumped 25% on an upbeat outlook, the Nasdaq 100 was on course for its best week since May by midweek, and AMD went through $1 trillion in market value (it's nearly tripled this year). Nvidia's results are due next week, and that's the one the whole market will be watching, although they’ve spent the week looking at Nvidia for very different reasons - and it’s taken a very big bath on the back of the CEO/spy scandal. Tech bros and marriages - the worst record of them all (about equal to high-profile comedians, maybe). The Governor of the Bank of England, in Zurich on Monday, said the risk of an AI bubble exists, set out four ways one could burst (everybody being priced to be a winner among them) and reminded his audience of Netscape. I said last week bull markets have half a dozen corrections or more, and that the hype around the Anthropic IPO was still to come - same view this week. One bounce doesn't change the cycle, in either direction.
So what does it all mean for a landlord in Sunderland or Newcastle? Oil is the good news - $95 against $118 three weeks ago is working its way through to the forecourt, slowly. The RAC had petrol at 168.45p on Tuesday, 6.5p below its 5th October high, and the AA reckons another 10p is due. Diesel is the laggard (the AA called it "dismal") - 197.27p on the RAC's count, only 3p below the record 200.20p of 5th October. It'll come down, but it won't come quickly, and the hauliers will feel it first. I’m just happy we haven’t seen the 205p average just yet (and might avoid it for this cycle, we can hope).
The bad news came from America's inflation. Hot US CPI and Waller's half point pushed Treasury yields up, gilts followed (with some help from our own Bank of England - more in the macro), and the 5-year swap, which is what your lender prices a five-year fix off, jumped 18 basis points between Thursdays. So we had oil helping and interest rates hurting in the same week, and for a geared landlord the rates part bites first. One man in the White House can still undo the lot, of course, in either direction......
Phew. OK - back to the comparative safety of the real time UK property market.
As is customary, Chris Watkin has been relentlessly crunching the portal numbers and publishing them at Property Industry Eye, and his analysis for Week 44 of 2026 is where it's at, as always. The series has gone from "dead" to "on life support" to "who told the buyers?", and this week it's "The UK property market is apparently at death's door" - with Nick Neill on the Stats Show and the agents of Ipswich under the microscope. Chris opens by saying someone might want to tell the buyers, because they're still buying. Quite! He then runs through the list of excuses we've all heard this autumn (the doom, the gloom, the Budget, the Gulf) and asks whether the market's really as bad as some agents need us to believe. You can guess his answer.
Supply first, as always. 28.7k new listings in Week 44, up from 27.5k the week before, against a 2026 weekly average of 35.4k and a 10-year average for the week of 28k. So a touch above normal for mid-November, after two weeks below it (the clocks and the Budget, as I said last week, and both are behind us now). The year to date is 1.557m listings, about 0.1% below 2025 on Chris's numbers, and still roughly 8% to 9% above the pre-Covid norm. My ready reckoner stays where it was - somewhere between 8% and 9% more listings than a normal market. Stock on the market was 758k on 1st November, against 742k a year earlier, 724k in 2024 and 664k in 2023 - down 6k over October, against about 10k over the same month last year, so we're still clearing a little slower than 2025 did. But we are clearing, and we might now have had that peak in terms of the supply glut, if the market holds on at this slower pace.
Demand. Gross sales agreed came in at 20.5k, from 21.8k - a drop of 5.9%, which happens to be exactly the average drop between Weeks 43 and 44 over the last decade (so it's the season, not a cliff). The 10-year average for the week is 22.5k, which puts us at about 91% of normal - the sixth week running somewhere in the 90% to 93% band. The year to date is 1.053m, 7.5% below 2025, 3.9% below 2024, 10.3% above 2023, 4% above 2017-19 and 2% below the average of the last decade. Put the two together and it's 1.557m listings against 1.053m sales agreed, or about 1.48 new listings for every sale - the same as last week and the week before (one week doesn't move this needle, of course), against about 1.37 at this point in 2025.
My humble pie trigger, as long-time readers know, is sales running 20%+ below normal. At 2% below the decade average for the year, and about 9% below it for the week, the pie stays firmly in the fridge (where, as I said last week, it might well go off before I need it). We don’t even need Jon Bon Jovi quite yet to tell us that we are halfway there.
Net sales, after the fall-throughs, were 14.9k against a 10-year average of 16.7k - nearer 89% of normal this week, because fall-throughs jumped to 27.4%, from 23.99%, against a decade average of 24.5%.
One week's fall-through rate bounces around, though. On the monthly measure, 5.42% of October's sales agreed fell through, against 5.1% for 2026 so far, 5.3% in 2025 and a 10-year average of 5.7% - so the deals are still sticking slightly better than normal over a month, if not this week. Net sales for the year are 810k, 6.6% below 2025, 3.5% below 2024, 13.3% ahead of 2023 and 2.1% above 2017-19.
Now the number I said every agent should read twice. Last week Chris's provisional count for October had only 49.2% of homes leaving agents' books actually selling, and I said I'd expect it to creep up a point or so as late exchanges came in. It's crept up a shade above two. The revised count has 66.8k exchanges against 62.9k withdrawals, so 51.5% of October's exits sold and 48.5% withdrew. Back above 50%, then, but still a long way short of the 7-year average of 57.6% - although that average includes the crazy post-lockdown years where 66% of transactions held together as buyers got heavily motivated.
The reductions held steady. 24k this week on 758k homes for sale (about 3.2% of everything on the market in a single week, and four weeks of that gets you to the 13% or so a month we've been seeing), with 13.7% of the stock reduced in October (from 14.7% in September), against a 2026 average of 13.1% and a 7-year average of 11%. The asking gap widened back out to 16.9%, from 15.5% - Chris's average new listing was £416k, up from £409k, against £356k for the homes going sale agreed, up from £354k. That's bang inside the long-term norm of 16% to 17%, and the move came mostly from the listings, not the buyers. Sell-through for October was 13.4%, as we covered last week, against 14.7% in September and 15.5% pre-Covid.
There's a new number in the pack this week, and it's one I'd like every vendor to have in front of them at the valuation. On a rolling 12-month basis, it's taking 76 days from listing to sale agreed and 122 days from sale agreed to completion - 198 days in all, or about six and a half months. So list your house on Monday 16th November, be exactly average, and you'll agree a sale around 31st January and complete around 2nd June 2027. And that's the good outcome - it assumes you're in the 51.5% that sell at all, and that you're not in the one in four deals that falls through and sends you back towards the start. If you're a landlord selling with vacant possession under Ground 1A, add the four months' notice on top, and you're looking at the best part of a year from deciding to sell to having the money.
And if you're signing a 12-week sole agency this month, remember the sell-through sum from last week - at 13.4% a month, only about 35% of sellers find a buyer inside 12 weeks. The ones who do sell take 76 days on average to agree, which is nearly 11 weeks, so even the successful ones are cutting it fine against a 12-week contract. You can see why Chris keeps banging the drum for eight-week terms - and why, as a vendor, I'd be asking for one. If we all refused to sign agreements longer than 12 weeks (we do, on the sales we undertake in our group) - we’d all be better off - stronger together, folks.
Rents next - and November is the first month where we can compare like with like again, with last October's student-inflated figure out of the way. The average new rental listing was £1,858 in Week 44 and £1,834 for November so far, against £1,769 in November 2025 - up 3.7% on the year. November 2021 was £1,449, so that's 26.6% up on five years, and the 2026 average is £1,767. With CPI at 3.5% in September, a 3.7% rise in asking rents is about flat in real terms - so tenants aren't being squeezed any harder than the rest of the shopping basket, whatever you might read elsewhere.
Rental stock was 320k on 1st November, against 323k a year earlier, and 149.7k new rental listings came to market in October, against 153k a year earlier and 116k in 2022. On my old yardstick (350k normal, 300k the new normal, 250k constricted) we're a touch looser than the new normal - but with the surveyors' rent expectations at their highest since early 2024 this week (more in the macro), I wouldn't read that as rents running out of puff. The other clearout week of the year comes around Christmas, so don't be surprised if the rental stock number drops sharply in late December - it does every year, and it doesn't mean the sky has fallen in.
And the number I said I was most looking forward to. Chris's latest price per square foot at sale agreed is £339.07, 0.8% lower than a year earlier (£341.95) and 12.5% higher than six years ago (£301.40). Chris always points out that this correlates to the Land Registry index with 98% accuracy, about five months ahead - so a minus 0.8% now points to Land Registry annual growth going negative around Easter 2027. That's just about what Chris said back in September, when he had it heading from about 2% towards zero by March (and I said that sounded about right). My own call from the same month was another couple of % off price per square foot before Christmas - from August's £338.41 we're actually a touch higher, so that one's looking a bit hopeful with six weeks to go, I'll admit.
So is the market at death's door? The buyers clearly haven't heard - 20,500 of them (net) agreed to buy this week, in the same week the surveyors told us they're the gloomiest about sales since July 2023, and the year to date is within 2% of a normal decade. What we've got is a market where the buyers set the price, the sellers are slowly accepting it (exits back above 50%, the gap back to normal), and it all takes about six and a half months. It's not death's door - it's a slow, heavy one, with a lot of people standing in the doorway arguing about the price.
What would I do with this? If you're buying, it's not a bad time to be one of those 20,500 - vendors are cutting, the gap's back to normal and the surveyors are gloomy, which is usually when the better deals get done. If you're selling, price it right on day one, because 198 days is the average and every reduction adds weeks to it. If you're a landlord, those rent numbers are telling you the tenants are still there and the supply isn't, so I'd think very hard before selling a well-let house into a soft market. And if you're an agent, Chris's question from last week still stands - what share of your instructions actually exchanged?
Chris's point on the show is that a lot of what agents blame on the market is really their own strategy - overvaluing to win the instruction, cutting fees, and putting off the pricing conversation for three months. "Winning the instruction is easy when you promise the homeowner what they want to hear," as he puts it. Having bought and sold a fair few in my time, I'd agree - and those 198 days are the price of getting that first conversation wrong. The Ipswich section at the end of the show is worth a watch if you're anywhere near Suffolk.
Chris - this is my weekly appreciation paragraph. Thanks for what you do! If you want some help positioning yourself as a local market expert - as an estate agent or any form of property professional - give Chris a shout! Either way give his channel www.youtube.com/@christopherwatkin a follow and some love, please!
OK. Over to the Macro Met Office this week - where the forecasters keep promising cloud, and the actual weather keeps coming in a few degrees warmer. Five things for you - third-quarter GDP and NIESR's tracker, the Bank of England's speakers (and there were plenty of them), the RICS survey for October, a bonus on short-term lets from the ONS, and then gilts and swaps, as ever. The forecasts themselves get the whole Deep Dive, so think of this as the weather we actually got.
Growth first, as it should be. The ONS's first estimate for the third quarter, out on Thursday, had GDP up 0.7% on the quarter - bang in line with the (heavily adjusted, I might add) consensus (and with NIESR's tracker, which had said 0.7% when it came out last month), after 0.5% in the second quarter and 0.6% in the first. We're 1.9% bigger than we were a year ago. September alone grew 0.2% and July was unrevised at 0.4% - the only fly in the ointment was August, revised down from 0.1% to flat. That's the ninth three-month rise in a row, and real GDP per head grew 0.7% on the quarter too, which you'd think would get more of a mention than it has. This is why I had to go for the forecasters in the Deep Dive this week (and because people have started asking for 2027 predictions, of course).
GDP is one thing - but GDP per head is another, and it is always a better measure. I think it tells us far more about the real economy than the headline does. It grew 0.7% on the quarter and 1.7% on the year, against 0.9% for the whole of 2025. With GDP itself up 1.9% on the year, nearly all of that growth is more output per person rather than more people, which sits rather awkwardly with the forecasters' gloom on productivity (more on them in the Deep Dive).
Its partner is real household disposable income per head - what's left in our pockets after tax and inflation, and the number that actually pays the rent. Long-time readers will know I love RHDI. The ONS doesn't publish it with the first estimate, so the third quarter's figure won't be out until 22nd December. The latest we have is the second quarter, when it rose 1.0% (the biggest jump since the end of 2024) after a 0.8% fall in the first, and households saved a touch more of it too, with the saving ratio up 0.2 points to 8.8%. More real income per head is more money in tenants' pockets - and with the economy growing as it did in the third quarter, I'd expect December's number to look decent, too. We need MORE RHDI and less saving, to be honest - and ideally less volatility as well, 1% change in a quarter is quite a lot (but at least last time out it was on the right side!).
What drove the growth? Services, completely, as so often - up 0.9% on the quarter, with business-facing services up 1.0% and consumer-facing services up 0.5%. Production edged up 0.1% (manufacturing up 0.9%, with computer and electronic products up 4.6% over the three months - hello, AI), and construction went backwards (more on that in a moment). The ONS says computer programming and consultancy was the biggest single contributor to growth.
Construction is the one I'd keep an eye on. It fell 0.7% on the quarter, but grew 0.8% in September alone (its strongest month since March, by NIESR's reading) - so perhaps the worst is behind it, although a housing index of 35.1 in last week's construction PMI tells us that the growth is elsewhere. I'll believe the “relevant” bounce when I see it in the housebuilders' completions, and I suspect we'll be waiting a while - a year, or more. We may have hit the bottom, is the best we can say, when it comes to new build construction.
On the spending side, households spent 0.6% more, the government 0.6% more, and business investment rose 0.4% (3.0% on the year), with total fixed investment up 1.7%. Nominal GDP - the cash size of the economy, which is what the tax take actually runs off - grew 1.4% on the quarter and 4.3% on the year. That last number is one the Chancellor will like a lot more than the headline, I suspect, because it's the one that fills the Treasury's coffers. Throw in the frozen thresholds and the income tax take is up more than 7% in nominal terms, year on year (oh yay!).
So where does that leave 2026? On 18th October I said growth this year was already running at about 1.8% on what we knew, and that the 1.2% consensus was wrong. Half right, I think. With August revised to flat, the sums for the calendar year come out at about 1.5% if the fourth quarter does nothing at all, and about 1.6% if it grows 0.4%, which is NIESR's call. So my 1.8% was a bit punchy - but the 1.2% the OBR printed on 28th October, and the consensus sat on for months, looks a lot further adrift than I was. I'll take 1.6% to 1.7% for 2026 now, and I'm going 1.5% to 1.7% for 2027 (more on that in the Deep Dive). The unknown is Q4 inflation, with the very recent figures just slipping away from us a little - I have been betting (metaphorically) on the unders, but 3.5%+ is not comfortable territory. More on inflation next week of course.
NIESR's tracker, out the same afternoon, pencils in 0.4% for the fourth quarter, with services steady and production slowing. Fergus Jimenez-England called it "an exceptional third quarter, with broad-based growth across production and services" - and then, in the next breath, said further rate rises are needed to keep inflation contained. That's the odd thing about a strong economy right now - every bit of good news on growth gets read as bad news for mortgages. Which is exactly how the gilt market read this week, as we'll see.
Why should we care, as property people? Because an economy growing at 0.7% a quarter (and 0.7% a head) is one where people keep their jobs, and people in work pay their rent and their mortgages - which is, of course, why the buy-to-let arrears count was falling on UK Finance's latest numbers, rather than rising as the doom-mongers expected. The flip side is that the Bank won't be in any rush to cut, and that's the price we pay for growth. I'll take that trade every time - you can always refinance a mortgage, but you can't refinance a recession.
Next up, the Bank of England's speakers, who were out in force in the week after the rise - and mostly sounding like people who'd quite like to do it again. The Governor was in Zurich on Monday, where he said UK activity is proving more resilient than expected, partly thanks to AI investment in business services, and that he sees the beginnings of a positive supply shock from it (alongside the bubble warning I mentioned in Trumpwatch). A positive supply shock is the good kind - more output without more inflation. If he's right about that, it's the best argument I've heard all year for being more relaxed about rates, not less.
Clare Lombardelli, the Deputy Governor for Monetary Policy, at the Bank of England Watchers' Conference on Tuesday, was the hawkish one. "I continue to think there is likely to be a case for a further increase in rates in the near term," she said, with the risks to inflation still to the upside and the labour market cooling mainly through weaker hiring rather than more firing. She also put AI at about 0.5 percentage points of growth since the start of the year. The market had about 13 basis points priced for December before she spoke and about 17 by midweek - and the 10-year gilt went from about 5.10% to over 5.20% during Tuesday's session (with America's inflation finishing the job that afternoon). Lloyds' economists, for what it's worth, reckon her vote looks more likely to come in February than December - which fits my own lean below.
Megan Greene told the FT on Wednesday the Bank should lean against the risk of wage growth getting stuck at higher levels - no surprise from one of the hawks. Sarah Breeden's line was that firms have got very good at adapting to cost shocks, which is the dovish end of the same argument (if they can absorb it, they don't pass it on). So we've one Committee, three or four different stories, and October's CPI on Wednesday to settle some of it.
Where does that leave my December call? Last week I had a hold, more like a 6-3 vote. I'm sticking with the hold - oil's another $2.50 lower on the week, and the Governor wants more data - but Lombardelli moving into the "likely" camp makes it closer than I'd like. If Wednesday's CPI comes in hot, 5-4 to hold becomes the likely score, and a rise isn't out of the question. February stays a 6-3 rise in my book, as I said last week (and NIESR, as we'll see in the Deep Dive, has exactly one more rise, in February, as its central case).
What does it mean for your mortgage? If you're on a tracker, a December rise would be another 25bp from January - about £21 a month for every £100,000 of interest-only debt. If you're fixing, the speeches matter more than the decision, because they move the swaps, and this week they moved them 18 basis points the wrong way. We tend to think mortgage rates get set at the Bank on a Thursday lunchtime - this week they were set in the swap market on a Tuesday afternoon.
Now the RICS survey for October, published on Thursday - the first one taken with a rate rise on the table, and the surveyors aren't happy. The headline price balance fell to minus 36, from a revised minus 34 (the weakest since November 2023, and worse than the consensus). New buyer enquiries were flat at minus 24, agreed sales fell to minus 24 from minus 18, and new instructions dropped back to minus 8, from plus 6. Looking ahead, the 12-month sales expectations balance fell to minus 17, the gloomiest since July 2023, and the 12-month price expectations balance went from zero to minus 17 - which the surveyors' own estimates translate into a fall of around 1% over the next year.
Tarrant Parsons at RICS said respondents are "bracing for a weaker year ahead for sales", and pointed to the Bank's warning that policy may need to tighten further. Fair enough - but RICS is a sentiment survey, and it's been gloomier than Chris's actual numbers for most of this year. An agreed sales balance of minus 24 sits alongside Chris's sales agreed at 91% of normal this week - the surveyors and the data are telling us the same story in different languages (the data says "a bit slow", the surveyors say "gloom"). And a 1% fall in 2027 sits between Savills' minus 1.5% (Deep Dive) and my own 0% to 0.5% - a bit closer to theirs than I'd like, but not by much.
The lettings side went the other way, and it's the bit I'd underline. Tenant demand turned positive at plus 7, from minus 1, landlord instructions were minus 30, and rent expectations for the next three months jumped to plus 41, from plus 29 - the highest since early 2024. Fewer landlords, more tenants, higher rents - you've read it here before, and Savills has just built the same thing into its five-year forecast. It's why I'm going 3.5% on the ONS's rent measure for 2027.
Now a bonus, because it landed on Friday and it's not something we get to cover often - the ONS's figures on short-term lets booked through the big three platforms (Airbnb, Booking.com and Expedia's brands) from July 2025 to June 2026. There were 104,617,530 guest nights in the year, up 10.2% on the year before and 22.9% on two years earlier. England had 77.5% of them, up 9.5%, with Scotland up 12.0% and Wales up 14.3% (the fastest, oddly enough, just as Wales brings in compulsory registration this autumn and lets councils charge a visitor levy from April 2027).
The North East grew fastest of the regions, up 17.3%, while London - still the biggest at 21.9m guest nights - grew only 5.4%. Domestic guests were up 13.4% and international ones only 4.1%, and nearly a quarter of all the guest nights were in just 9 of the 361 local authorities (Westminster, Cornwall and North Yorkshire among them, with Liverpool, Edinburgh and the Highlands not far behind). Cornwall alone added 394,430 guest nights, up 10.8% to just over 4m, and Westminster added 380,940 - so the holiday hotspots got busier, not quieter, through a year of war and £2 diesel.
What do I make of it? Holiday lets lost their special tax treatment in April 2025, and guest nights went up 10% anyway - so the demand is clearly there, and it's mostly us Brits holidaying at home. But the ONS is careful to say these numbers can't be de-duplicated and don't cover all short-term letting, so I wouldn't build a business plan on them alone. And for anyone weighing a holiday let against a long let under the Renters' Rights Act, the regulation is still coming in England (the national register was first proposed in February 2024 and still hasn't arrived) - so I'd price that risk in before buying, not after.
Gilts and swaps, then - and this week gave back everything last week gave us, and a bit more besides - black armbands at the ready. Friday's closes first. The 5-year closed at 4.879%, up 20.4 basis points on last week's 4.675%. The 30-year closed at 5.790%, up 17.8 on last week's 5.612%. The 10-year finished at 5.344%, up 18.9 from 5.155%. So last week's 14.4bp fall on the 5-year has been more than reversed - although the 10-year is still some way below the 5.5% or so it touched in early October, which was the highest since 2007.
Why? Tuesday did most of the damage - Lombardelli's hawkish turn in the morning, then America's hot inflation and Waller's half point in the afternoon. Thursday's GDP was in line, so it didn't add much either way. And oil at $95 didn't help gilts this week the way $98 did last week - the bond market had already banked the oil, and it was busy pricing the central banks instead. Then what we imported from the hot US inflation figures, of course.
Sterling had a rough week against the dollar too - down 0.9% on Tuesday alone, with the dollar at its highest since May 2025 by Thursday. A weaker pound makes imports dearer (oil included, as it's priced in dollars), so it takes some of the shine off oil's fall for us - and it's one more reason the Bank's hawks won't be in a hurry to declare victory.
Against a year ago, the 5-year is about 86 basis points higher (it was c. 4.02%) and the 30-year about 39 higher (c. 5.40%). The 52-week ranges haven't moved - 3.668% to 5.106% on the 5-year and 5.033% to 6.073% on the 30-year. The gap between the 5-year and the 30-year narrowed to 91 basis points, from 94, because the short end rose further.
The curve has the 1-year at 4.680%, the 2-year at 4.984% and the 3-year at 4.992%, then a dip to 4.933% at four years and 4.879% at five, before stepping up to 5.114% at six (the same benchmark step as last week), 5.344% at ten and 5.790% at thirty. With Bank Rate at 4.00% and the 2-year back near 5%, the market's pricing more rises again - and my 4.25% for the end of 2027 is a fair way below where the curve sits. As the Governor said last week, a lot of that is risk premium rather than a forecast, and I'm with him. Sticking with it - not hopium, but not guaranteed either. After this week it looks like we’d have to make a round trip via 4.5% back downwards, and I’m punting a bit that the nerfing of Trump in the house and the senate does some of the legwork (whilst I’m nowhere near as hopeful as some of the commentators are that “the grownups are back in the room”).
The swaps, which is what your lender actually prices off - BlueGamma's series, Thursday to Thursday. The 5-year SONIA swap closed Thursday at 4.77%, up 18 basis points on the previous Thursday's 4.59%. The 3-year closed at 4.81%, up 20 from 4.61%, and the 2-year at 4.73%, from 4.53%. A month ago the 5-year was 4.81% and the 3-year 4.78%, so we're back about where we were in mid-October, and against a year ago the 5-year is 108 basis points higher and the 3-year 122. The 2-year at 4.73% says, roughly speaking, that the market expects Bank Rate to average something like 4.6% to 4.7% over the next two years.
The 3-year is within a basis point of its 52-week high (4.82%), and it's still above the 5-year - so the market still expects rates to come back down after a year or two, which I'd agree with. My call is the 5-year swap at 4% by the end of 2027. The 5-year gilt (4.879%) is also still above the 5-year swap (4.77%), by about 11 basis points - the government paying more to borrow for five years than the banks charge each other, even on BlueGamma's mid-point numbers. QT and the sheer weight of supply, as I keep saying, and I'll keep saying it until it goes away.
And here's the twist. My working margin over the 5-year swap for limited company money is about 1.75%, and 4.77% plus 1.75% is 6.52%. Last week I was "a step away" from my 6.5% call, at 6.34% - this week the swap's put us right on it. I'm not booking it yet (it's a six-month call, made in September, and one Thursday doesn't make it - I'd want to see lenders' rate sheets there, and staying there). If the 5-year swap is back at 4% by the end of next year, as I expect, limited company five-year money would be nearer 5.75% by then. For now, though, 6.5% is where the sums are. It’s much easier predicting a few months away than a whole year with everything that’s in the mixer at the moment.
If you've a refinance coming up, last week's advice needs an update. I said the better deals should drift in over a few weeks - well, the swaps have just gone back up 18 basis points, so the drift may go the other way now, and lenders follow swaps up a lot faster than they follow them down. If you've an offer you're happy with, I'd think hard before waiting for a better one. Get your broker to check, and then check again. TAKE THE PRICES THAT ARE IN FRONT OF YOU - THAT’S WHAT I’M DOING, ANYWAY.
OK. Here endeth the lesson on current rates - here comes the Deep Dive.
This week it's the forecasters, and a first pass at 2027. We've four sets of numbers - the OBR's October forecast, which the Budget was built on (four themes, because it's the one that sets our taxes, so I'm going to town on it), then the international referees, the IMF and the OECD, then NIESR's autumn outlook from Wednesday, and Savills' new five-year forecasts for prices and rents. What connects them? Burke, at the top - every one of them plans the future at least partly by the past, and in my view every one of them is too slim on growth. I've put my own 2027 numbers alongside theirs as we go. If you only read one bit this week, make it the OBR's housing theme - it's where you'll find a forecaster who thinks the economy is weak and house prices are strong, both at once.
First up, the OBR's Economic and fiscal outlook, published on Budget day, Wednesday 28th October. It's the forecast that decides how much headroom the Chancellor has, so it's the one that decides how much tax we pay - which is why it gets four themes, not two.
Theme 1: Stronger Than Expected, Still 1%
The Summary: The OBR says recent GDP growth has been stronger than it expected, and judges the strength to be structural. It forecasts growth of 1.2% in 2026 and around 1% in 2027, about half a point below its March forecast for 2027, because higher energy prices and interest rates take time to weigh on activity. It puts GDP just over 1% below potential, with the gap widening in the second half of 2026, and growth averaging 1.75% a year after 2027.
The Propenomix Perspective: So the strength is structural - and yet 2027 is half a point weaker than they thought in March? I can't make those two sentences sit together, to be honest. Two weeks after the OBR printed 1.2%, the ONS gave us 0.7% for the third quarter - the very half-year where the OBR had the output gap getting wider. I'm going 1.5% to 1.7% for 2027, because the war hasn't had the impact everyone expected, it's largely under wraps, and it's more likely to end now than it was before the midterms. I said on 25th October the ruler should sit on the optimistic side - this one doesn't, quite. Too much downside and not enough upside, for me - and inflation has been slower than expected which is why growth has been higher than expected, to an extent - plus AI of course….
Theme 2: Oil at $95, Inflation at 3.8%
The Summary: The OBR forecasts CPI inflation of 3.1% in 2026 and 3.4% in 2027, peaking at 3.8% early in 2027 and back to 2% in 2028. It assumes oil falls from a $95 peak in the second quarter of 2026 to $70 to $75 by 2028, and gas reaches about 150p a therm at the end of 2026, falling to about 95p by late 2027. It puts a one-in-five chance on CPI above 4.5% in 2027.
The Propenomix Perspective: That was written before the Bank's November report, which has a 4.9% peak built on Brent at $108 and gas at 216p. Brent settled at $95.84 on Friday - so, for once, the OBR's oil assumption is closer to the real world than the Bank's (for now, at least). My peak forecast of "closer to 4 than 5" sits nearer the OBR than the Bank. But I'm going 3.5% for CPI at the end of 2027, which is stickier than either of them has it by then - legacy inflation from Covid takes years to wash out, and the wage round is still to come. Brent at $75 by the end of 2027 is my guess too (way outside my wheelhouse, that one), which lines up with their $70 to $75.
Theme 3: Headroom, and the £16bn Lever
The Summary: The forecast assumes Bank Rate reaches just over 4.25% by mid-2027 and just over 4.5% by the end of the forecast. Headroom against the stability rule is £15bn in 2029-30, with a 56% probability of meeting it. Debt interest rises from £109bn (3.5% of GDP) in 2025-26 to £160bn (4.2%) in 2031-32. A one-point change in interest rates moves debt interest by about £16bn, and productivity growth half a point higher or lower moves borrowing by £50bn or £40bn.
The Propenomix Perspective: The rate path here is the market's curve, not a forecast - and for once my 4.25% for Bank Rate at the end of 2027 sits just below it rather than miles away (we'll be slow to cut again, in my view). The bigger lever is growth. Half a point more productivity is worth £50bn by 2030-31, and the OBR has unemployment peaking just above 5% in the middle of next year, against my 4.5% at the end of 2027. More people in work, more tax, fewer claims. I backed the overs on headroom before the Budget and it landed at £15bn - I'd back the overs again by the spring.
Theme 4: 2% and 220,000 Homes
The Summary: The OBR expects house prices to rise around 2% in 2026 and 2.5% in 2027, then about 2.75% a year from 2028. Transactions run at about 1.2m in 2026, rising to about 1.3m in 2031. Net additions to the housing stock fall from about 230,000 in 2025-26 to 220,000 in 2026-27 and 2027-28, before reaching 260,000 in 2030-31, 190,000 fewer in total than in March. The effective rate on the mortgage stock rises from 4% in 2026 to around 5% in 2031.
The Propenomix Perspective: Too slim on growth and too fat on house prices - quite a combination! With Lloyds down 1.2% on the year and Chris's price per square foot down 0.8%, I can't see 2% for 2026. My final number for 2026 is up 1.25%, and 0% to 0.5% for 2027 stands, against their 2.5%. Transactions? I'm going close to 1m next year, much like this year, rather than their 1.2m. And 220,000 new homes a year against a target of 300,000 is the laughable bit. The number I'd actually plan on is the stock mortgage rate heading for 5% by 2031 - and the £0.4bn a year they expect from squeezing landlords' income tax, which is a lot of lemon for not much juice - that Prudence Penalty.
Next up, the international referees - the IMF's World Economic Outlook, "Resilience Under Strain, Urgent Choices", published on 13th October during the annual meetings in Bangkok, and the OECD's interim outlook, "Weathering Successive Shocks", from 23rd September. Both were written before the third-quarter GDP figures, which is rather the point.
Theme 1: The IMF's Fourth Quarter
The Summary: The IMF projects UK growth of 1.3% in 2026, up 0.3 points from July and 0.5 points from April, and 1.2% in 2027, down 0.1, as higher energy prices and long-term interest rates weigh on consumption and investment. Measured fourth quarter on fourth quarter, it has 1.4% for 2026 and 1.5% for 2027. Its forecasts assume the Strait of Hormuz reopens from March 2027, with oil averaging about $96 a barrel in 2026 and $87 in 2027.
The Propenomix Perspective: Here's a sum you can check. The third quarter is already 1.9% bigger than a year earlier, so for the year to the fourth quarter to come in at 1.4%, the economy would have to shrink by about 0.4% between October and December, on my sums. Nobody I've read expects that (NIESR has growth of 0.4%). The IMF went 0.8% in April, 1.0% in July, 1.3% in October, and the data now say 1.5% to 1.6% - chasing the economy up the hill all year. Their 1.2% for 2027 has the same problem. They're also more bearish on oil than I am ($87 for 2027 against my $75), which drags their growth down too.
Theme 2: The OECD's Conservation of Pessimism
The Summary: The OECD's interim report raised its UK growth forecast for 2026 to 1.1%, from 0.9% in June and 0.7% in March, and trimmed 2027 to 1.0%, from 1.1%, citing the drag from higher interest rates, according to reports of the UK figures. It sees global growth of 2.9% in 2026 and 3.0% in 2027, and G20 inflation of 4.1% in 2026 easing to 3.6% in 2027. The shadow chancellor, Andrew Griffith, said the 2027 figure was a third of the G20 average.
The Propenomix Perspective: Notice the pattern? Every time 2026 goes up, 2027 comes down - a sort of conservation of pessimism, where the total gloom stays the same and just moves to next year. The OECD's 1.0% for 2027 is the lowest of the lot, alongside the OBR. The strength of 2026 has been AI, business investment, defence and firms absorbing the energy shock rather than passing it on, and the forecasters treat all of it as luck that's about to run out. Maybe it will - but it's run for three quarters now. (And the G20 average includes the likes of India, growing at 6% or 7% a year, so I'd take Mr Griffith's comparison with a pinch of salt.) They all just seem to look at the negative and weigh it much harder than the positive, at this time.
Third up, NIESR - the National Institute's autumn UK Economic Outlook, "Decisions Deferred", published on Wednesday 11th November. It's the freshest forecast of the lot, finished after the Bank's rise and a day before the GDP figures.
Theme 1: 1.6%, Then 1.1%, Then 0.9%
The Summary: NIESR raises its 2026 growth forecast to 1.6%, from 1.1% in July, in line with the Bank and above the OBR's 1.2%, then expects 1.1% in 2027, 0.9% in 2028 and 1.2% to 1.5% a year from 2029 to 2031. It puts trend growth at about 1.3%, assuming trend productivity growth of 1.0%, which it calls optimistic given average growth of only 0.4% a year from 2008 to 2023. Sustained $100 oil could leave GDP up to 0.6% lower by 2028.
The Propenomix Perspective: Credit where it's due - NIESR is the first of the big forecasters to put 2026 where the data actually are. But 0.9% for 2028 is Burke's point in action. That 0.4% a year from 2008 to 2023 covers a financial crisis, austerity, Brexit and a pandemic, and I'd argue it's a poor guide to an economy where AI alone has added half a point to growth this year, if Lombardelli's right. Their adverse case is sustained $100 oil - and we're at $95.84 and falling. I'm at 1.5% to 1.7% for 2027 against their 1.1%, and I'd be surprised if they don't edge up by the spring.
Theme 2: Behind the Curve
The Summary: NIESR sees CPI peaking at 4.4% in February 2027, averaging 3.9% across 2027 and returning to 2% only in late 2030, about two years after the OBR and the Bank. Its central case has one more rise, to 4.25% in February, then gradual cuts to 3.5% by mid-2030, but it judges market pricing of about 4.75% closer to what's needed, and the forecast team writes that it thinks the MPC is behind the curve.
The Propenomix Perspective: Funnily enough, my 4.25% for Bank Rate at the end of 2027 matches NIESR's central case to the letter, and so does my February rise. Where we part company is "behind the curve". The curve is mostly risk premium, as the Governor said last week, and following it to 4.75% would be paying for a war that's winding down. On inflation I'm closer to NIESR than I'd like to admit (3.5% at the end of 2027, against their 3.9% average for the year), because I think it'll be sticky. But sticky inflation from administered prices and a wage round isn't something another two rises fix quickly, in my view.
Last up, Savills, whose Residential Forecasts 2027-2031 came out on Wednesday 4th November - mainstream prices from Dan Hill and Emily Williams, and rents from Dan Doherty and Chris Buckle. I touched on the price numbers last week, but they belong next to everyone else's.
Theme 1: Groundhog Day
The Summary: Savills forecasts mainstream UK prices flat in 2026 and down 1.5% in 2027, a peak-to-trough fall of about 3%, before rises of 3.5% in 2028, 5% in 2029 and 2030 and 3% in 2031 - 15.8%, or £56,500, over five years, against forecast CPI of 9.8% and income growth of 14.4%. It expects average mortgage rates to fall below 5% only in early 2028. London falls 3.5% in 2027 and gains 8.1% over five years, with the North, Wales and Scotland strongest.
The Propenomix Perspective: Savills had 2026 down 2% in the spring and now has it flat - and my final number for 2026 is up 1.25%. So they were too gloomy on this year, and I think they're too gloomy on next year too (minus 1.5% against my 0% to 0.5%). Their recovery hangs on mortgage rates getting under 5%, and with the 5-year swap at 4% by the end of 2027, as I expect, I'd see that a little sooner than early 2028 - and buyers tend to move before the rates actually get there, as they always do. A year ago, before the war, they had 22.2% over five years (not the 22.8% I misremembered last week). London syndrome, as I said - and the houses-over-flats point (44% against 14% over the last decade) is one I'd underline twice.
Theme 2: The Missing 240,000
The Summary: Savills expects rents to grow faster than wages until the end of 2027, then broadly in line with incomes, with London rising faster. Rent takes 32% of income in the UK and 37% in London, against peaks of 34% and 39% two years ago. It estimates the rental market has lost a net 240,000 homes in four years, while 22,000 build to rent homes were completed in the year to September, with starts down more than 70%. Average yields offer no premium over gilts.
The Propenomix Perspective: Build to rent isn't the cavalry, then. 22,000 completions in a year against about 60,000 homes a year leaving the sector is a lot of ground to make up, and with starts down 70% it's going backwards. That's why I'm going 3.5% on ONS rents for 2027. On yields, Savills has a point, sadly - Rightmove's gross yield of 6.6%, less 25% for costs, is about 4.95% net, against a 10-year gilt at 5.344%. The premium has to come from the capital growth and the shortage, which is a long game (it always was, of course). And that 240,000 is before April 2027's Prudence Penalty lands - so if anything I'd expect the outflow to speed up next year rather than slow down, which is the very risk Savills calls "not insubstantial".
So that's the first pass at 2027 - mine sits a good way above the forecasters on growth, a touch above them on inflation, and well below the OBR on house prices. I'll refine it as the year closes, and I'd like to hear where you think I'm wrong.
The Week Ahead. A big week for inflation. Tuesday 17th brings the labour market from the ONS (three segments, as ever, and pay), along with NIESR's wage tracker. Wednesday 18th is the main event - October's CPI, the first proper test of the Bank's 4.9% and probably the number that decides December - with producer prices, the ONS house price index and private rents alongside it, and the Treasury's monthly comparison of independent forecasts (I'll be counting how many have caught up with 1.6%). On Wednesday and Thursday, the APEC summit in Shenzhen might give us the Trump, Xi and Putin photograph, and perhaps something on Iran. Friday 20th has October's retail sales and the public finances, with borrowing set against the OBR's new profile. In America, Nvidia's results will set the tone for the AI trade. Further out, Ofgem's January cap lands on 25th November and the Bank's Money and Credit on 30th November. Plenty to chew on before January's workshop!
As we get towards the end for this week - I can't wait for our next workshop in Birmingham on Thursday 7th January 2027, with Rod Turner. Strategic Planning, Productivity, Systems and Processes, and Financial Management and Reporting, all in one day - and with the forecasters all pencilling in a slow 2027, it's the businesses with a plan of their own that'll do best out of it. I’ve always done best when it comes to acquisitions when prices aren’t really moving either way. Super Early Bird has 20%+ off, and the tickets are on sale at tinyurl.com/AdamRod27. The VIP dinner tickets are the most limited of all - grab one if you want time with Rod and myself on your own situation!
Above all, always remember to Keep Calm, ALWAYS listen to or read the Supplement, and Carry On. Remember those fundamentals - the shortage of two and three bed homes, and the fact that investing in property is never a guaranteed win. This week the economy grew 0.7% in a quarter when it was supposed to be on its knees, oil fell for a second week running, and over 20,000 buyers a week kept turning up. The forecasters will catch up eventually - they usually do, a quarter or two late.
My first pass at 2027 is in the Deep Dive - growth of 1.5% to 1.7%, CPI at 3.5% and Bank Rate at 4.25% by the end of the year, unemployment at 4.5%, ONS rents up 3.5%, house prices 0% to 0.5% and the 5-year swap back at 4%. If I'm anywhere near right, 2027 is a year for buying well rather than a year for hiding. If I'm wrong - well, that's what the stress numbers are for, and you'll hear it here first......
KCCO!